2002 TRENCHES PF 10
Katherine Blanchard, Field Supervisor
Reports from the end of the field season
of Trench PF 10, Katherine (Katy) Blanchard.
The return from the four-day
break, whether spent near a beach or in a museum, always revives
the energy in the trench. Four days to clear our heads from the
muggy weather of the Mugello and also of the confusion of the
View of Trench PF 10 at the end of Week 4.
This week has seen a
pass throughout the entire trench. What this means is that we
are better able to see the rock and tile as it lies on the exterior
of the structure. PF 6 has been reopened and the balk we had
left between that trench and ours was taken down today (this
balk had been left so that our scarps would read the stratigraphy
of the field, not the refilled trench). The wall that enters
Locus 1 on the western side has been more clearly defined.
Michael Joyce and Rebecca Cooper working in Trench PF 10.
Have our questions been
answered? In some cases, yes. The burned feature is burned into
Stratum 3, not lying upon it. The only artifacts, broken and
full, come from within 1.5 meters of the wall. The rest of the
trench is upon sterile soil. And Michael, Andy, Hillery, and
Rebecca have been indefatigable in their efforts to finish our
passes, especially when it's slow going through the hardened
and sometimes sterile soil. It is important to discover that
this is an uninhabited area--to put the perimeter on the land
the Etruscans were using.
Left: Andy Bozanic removing the balk between PF 10 and 6. Right:
Rebecca Cooper digging in PF 10.
Hillery Pous making a new pass in Trench PF 10.
To further explore this,
two sets of non-intrusive survey have occurred. Last week, Dr.
Frank Vento led a Ground Penetrating Radar survey south of our
excavated areas. This week, Dr. Dario Monna ran resistivity tests
in the same area. We are looking forward to the results of these
surveys--as they do not harm the site in the way that a shovel-test-pit
But perhaps the most
important thing we learned this week is: Don't eat the berries.
Left: Jungle Boogie Monkey. Right: Assistant Field Supervisor
Crew of Trenches PF 10
& 12 making the best of the rain and mud, left to right:
Hillery Pous, Katy Blanchard, Andy Bozanic, Michael Joyce, and
Rain is a part of the archaeological
experience. The overcast skies made the flowers near where the
students are picked up brighter, and also kept the soil from
baking in the noonday heat. However, it also seeps in under the
plastic tarp and silts up the corners. This week has simply proven
to me that Andy, Hillery, Rebecca and Michael are true excavators--barefoot
and dripping they continued the passes. We have tried to finish
the definition of the feature, but the dampness of the soil has
made determining the edges difficult. Today the sun came out
and the edges of the trench are starting to dry.
Trench PF 10 covered to
protect it from the heavy rains of Week 5.
The beginning of this pass involved pulling
the rock and tile at that level and taking a 5 cm pass underneath
all of this. However, as this pass was completed, they came across
more rock on top of more tile. This means that we still have
one more pass to take to understand the spill from the wall.
View of Trench PF 10 from the south.
The students have asked many good questions
this week: if this is wall spill, why are there tiles underneath
and on top of it? As we define the feature, it appears to be
in line with the corner stone in the building, so does this mean
it could have been a corner post that has fallen? Since there
do not seem to be any significant tile pieces, how can the carbonized
wooden feature be a roof-bearing piece? All good questions. And
right now all we can say is that perhaps the rubble at this level
is only indicative of an earlier wall phase. The carbonized wooden
feature has grown considerably smaller as we have more carefully
defined the edges of the feature and the edges of the stain.
It is not likely a large beam but likely smaller twigs as part
of a wall construction.
Next week is the last week. And we will
only have this one last pass to answer our questions.
Detail of Trench PF 10.
The end of the season has seen the opening
of a new trench to test the results of a magnotometry survey
done last week. PF12 is set up as a 5m X 5m trench, on the grid,
exactly 10m south of PF 5. This season will only see the excavation
of the NW locus, Locus 1.
Michael Joyce and Lynn Makowsky clearing for the opening of Trench
We expected to be finished in PF10 and
expanded, if you will, into the center of the field to see if
there was in fact a building on this flatter section of the land.
The resisitivity survey that Andy and I ran a few weeks ago also
came up with a large anomaly in this corner and we are hoping
that there is a wall, and not an early upcropping of bedrock
below the surface.
The trench was opened yesterday afternoon,
with rotating members of PF10 trying to use their larger tool
skills once again. They had finally finessed the use of a dental
pick and then I gave them a shovel.
Katy Blanchard with Hillery Pous, Andy Bozanic, and Justin Gosses
in PF 12.
My assistant, Michael Joyce, has been
a great help as this new trench opens. We will have both trenches
running at the same time, just far enough away that the students
need to yell if they have a question.
Thus far, a 30cm pass has been taken
in the trench and soon we will sink a sounding locus in the NW
corner to find the bottom of plow zone so that we can finish
the plow zone in two passes. At this point, plow zone could be
from 5 to 20 more cm.
Andy Bozanic excavating in Trench PF 12.
Justin Gosses, working in Trench PF 12, is also here to conduct
tests on our kilns.
Week 6 (NOTE: Be sure
to read the reports for both trenches below):
corsage still life.
The last week, and as
of the writing of this report, one day of excavation left. The
end of the season is when you think you have arrived at conclusions,
and then something new is discovered.
Carbonized feature in Trench PF 10.
Today, between the feature
and the wall, where we thought we had scraped down to Stratum
3, we found more of the feature at a lower depth. Not much lower
and so this begs to be answered, were we not really on top of
sterile soil? Also included in this new patch of unexcavated
soil was a large tile. Tomorrow will see the definition of the
edge of the feature, the previously sterile soil, and the wall.
View of Trench PF 10 from the south during Week 6.
We had thought that PF10
would be finished by earlier this week; however, every day as
Rebecca and Hillery continued to clean and define we realized
that another pass should be taken and that the wall could be
defined more. They have kept PF10 together now that PF12 is running.
Next week will be the
final report, and perhaps then we will have some more answers.
Cooper excavating beneath roof tile
projecting from the scarp in Trench PF 10.
Hillery Pous taking a pass
in Trench PF 10 during Week 6.
Justin Gosses and Hillery Pous in Trench PF 10.
whole crew must work in PF 12, a decoy is left in PF 10.
As of the writing of
this report, Andy and Michael have taken PF12 down to about 1
meter in depth. This is no small feat, considering the heat,
the soil, and the height to shovel the soil into the wheelbarrow
[I lost this "skill" about 20 cm ago]. And what has
and Michael Joyce at work in PF 12 under Katy Blanchard's watchful
A stratum previously
unknown in the FOD. There is, in fact, a stratum of soil that
represents time between the Etruscans and today. And so far,
this stratum is about 65 centimeters deep. This soil is not sterile,
it does have a very few grotty bits. There were roots found throughout
the locus, and thus it could be evidence of bioturbation. However,
the pieces are not near the roots. Also found were a fineware
base, modern tile with finish, a small piece of modern concrete,
and a piece of plastic we like to think of as the augur's staff
from the Posable Augur-Action-Figure.
they finally found something in PF 12: a coarseware base fragment.
Hillery Pous, Katy Blanchard, Michael Joyce, and Andy Bozanic
At the close of today,
an unusual soil stain had appeared, as well as a large upcropping
of clay. The clay here appears to be yellow, green, and the blue/grey
we are used to. What we don't have is bedrock or the soil we
associate with being above bedrock.
Trench PF 12 during Week 6.
Tomorrow, I anticipate
finishing this pass and seeing if the clay was perhaps the anomaly
on the surveys. I would also like to take a 1m x 1m section in
the corner and take that down to bedrock to explore the depths
of the field in this flat plateau.
examples of The Archaeologist's "hmmm" Pose.
Trench PF 10
Field Supervisor Katy Blanchard and Assistant Field Supervisor
It is archaeological
tradition for the last few days of excavation to throw a few
surprises into the picture. This year, in PF10, we were indeed
surprised. As Hillery and Rebecca finished the last pass through
what remained of Stratum 2, they realized that our carbonized
wood feature was appearing at a lower elevation than we had noticed
it before. At higher elevations it was much lighter, but at this
level it was almost pure black.
Carbonized wood feature in Trench PF 10.
To ascertain an approximate
depth of our carbonized wood feature, we had previously defined
it and saw that it was about 2cm thick on its eastern edge in
Locus 4. As Hillery realized it was pure carbon on the western
side below this, we started to rethink our feature.
We investigated the area
where Locus 1 and Locus 4 met, between the feature's western
edge and the wall. Here, we discovered a large flange tile. This
was one of our surprises. We had assumed that because when we
defined this feature from the east and saw it on sterile soil,
and that because there had been no pottery inclusions throughout
the entire feature, that the feature was wood [something like
a pile of wood set outside a wall] burned into the stratum. This
tile proved us incorrect. After we extracted it, we realized
it was actually on top of Stratum Three--that there was a pit
dug into the lower stratum that perhaps this burned feature covered.
With only Friday left to excavate, I had Hillery and Rebecca
work on clearing this out so that the pit could be dug and we
could attempt to rethink the order of how things occurred.
View of Trench PF 10 from the south at the end of the 2002 season.
Friday afternoon, Rebecca
started to discover bone fragments. Bone inclusions are not unusual
for our trench. However, after trying to isolate the fragment,
she realized it was several fragments. And several large fragments.
We set out to remove as many as possible intact, trying to identify
any of them. It started to rain lightly while we were excavating
the bone, and our trench mates were very kind in holding the
plastic over us while we continued scraping at the fragments,
hoping to make progress.
Due to the lost days
during our week of rain, we also dug on Saturday. Rebecca finished
excavating the bone fragments before we went down on Saturday
afternoon. These fragments were not very large, but identifiable
amongst them were an end of a long bone, a tarsal fragment, and
several teeth. These were in a line and hard to identify in the
soil at first, but soon we all grew accustomed the difference
in color and density.
On Sunday I finished
excavating the pit, to find its dimensions and while digging,
I came across a lot more bone, and another grouping of several
teeth. Both times they appeared in a line; however, they did
not appear in a jaw, or near anything that I could positively
identify at this time as a jaw. Both sets appear to be two or
three small teeth, all animal, and no where near the size of
a tooth that Hillery removed from the wall packing last week.
While defining the edges
of the feature at this new lower elevation, body sherds of black
glaze started to appear more frequently. Throughout the week,
Hillery was coming upon black glaze body sherds all throughout
this area. On Sunday, a full base, with incised line, was found.
It became clear while defining the feature that the other pit,
with the bone, was separate from this pit, of black glaze, by
a wall of Stratum 3. That is to say, that Stratum 3 existed and
two separate pits were dug into it and used. Due to the lack
of time in the season, the second pit was not dug out. I believe
that more of this black glaze vessel will be found within this
View of Trench PF 10 from the north at the end of the 2002 season.
The end of the season
brought us full circle: we have found the wall we knew would
continue through this locus. We did not find any other walls,
thus giving us a dimension to the structure in the FOD. We found
a carbonized wood feature, which was assumed to be a stack of
wood lying outside a structure used in pottery production [that
is, a very useful stack of wood] that had burned into the top
of Stratum 3. The last few days showed us that before this burning
occurred, at least two pits had been dug outside. I do not opine
one pit was purely for bone, and one for black glaze. Without
excavating the second pit, we do not know what else it holds.
It could contain more bone. The most notable thing about the
bone fragment pit is its proximity to the wall: it is within
20 cm of the wall. For people to have a refuse pit that close
to their habitation is unusual. Further, the bones were in very
small fragments, and not a full variety is represented [no skull,
vertebrae, ribs, pelvic, etc. fragments were found]. Why a second
pit was dug right to its east, so that they almost touch, is
also puzzling. What purpose did they serve?
Trenches PF 10 and 12, left to right: Hillery Pous,
Katy Blanchard, Andy Bozanic, Michael Joyce, and Rebecca Cooper.
Unfortunately, we did
not answer all of our questions. However, we learned that what
you answer at the beginning is often unanswered by the end. I
thank my trench team, Michael Joyce, Andy Bozanic, Rebecca Cooper,
and Hillery Pous for such a wonderful season; they helped all
W.T.F. breaks go much more smoothly.
Andy Bozanic finishes definition of a foundation wall in Trench
Students and staff from all trenches backfill PF 10 (and other
trenches) in the Podere Funghi.
Trench PF 12
The end of the season
is just after the beginning of the season for PF12. Which can
be frustrating and rewarding, to have a mini season within the
larger one. Andy and Michael continued digging through our Stratum
2 [because PF12 is not connected to any other trenches, the strata
are labeled, as always, sequentially. However, the Stratum 2
in PF12 is different than Stratum 2 in PF10. It is the second
stratum that we came upon, in this case, what Michael pointed
out so clearly was unplowed Stratum 1. At one point, I had them
take a 30 cm pass.
Stratum 2 held no pottery
inclusions, leading us to believe that perhaps while our soil
was sterile of artifacts, it wasn't necessarily near bedrock.
With only one day left in the season, we decided to start a sounding
locus [1m x 1m] in the NW corner of the trench and dig it straight
down to bedrock. This way we would learn the stratigraphy of
this area of the field.
View of Trench PF 12 from the east at the end of the 2002 season.
Stratum 2 was in essence
a stratum never before seen in the FOD. In the structure currently
being excavated, there was plow zone [Stratum 1], and Stratum
2 [occupied] and Stratum 3 [sterile]. Our strat 2 was new and
it proved to be deep.
The entire locus was
at approximately 1 meter in depth when the sounding locus was
started. Andy and Michael had come upon large upcroppings of
clay all along the eastern half of the trench. They painstakingly
defined this clay as I started to dig to bedrock in our mini-locus.
At 135cm, we found bedrock
sheeting through the clay at the bottom of our locus. This proved
to us that the FOD's bedrock undulates throughout the entire
field and that perhaps there are other structures out there that
are much lower in depth than we originally thought.
View of Trench PF 12 from the west at the end of the 2002 season.
The resistivity survey
marks differences in sounding waves. Clay will be different than
soil. Walls will be different than soil. However, they will both
show up with the same lines on a survey. There is no way to tell
if it is a wall or clay until you dig. PF12 found clay veins
where we did not expect them, as well finding almost 100cm of
Results of resistivity
prospection in an area of the Podere Funghi.
The transported crew
of PF10, Michael Joyce, Andy Bozanic, Rebecca Cooper, and Hillery
Pous proved to be wonderful sports at this experimental trench.
Michael and Andy didn't even seem to mind working in the pit,
especially if I told them when a wind was blowing so that they
could stand up. I thank them for their spirit, in the Optimistic
Katy's Pool. Photo by Joe Cosentino.
Lifeguard: Andy Bozanic. Swimmers: Robert Belanger and Katy Blanchard.
Why are they always laughing? Left to right: Hillery Pous, Andy
Michael Joyce, and Katy Blanchard. Photo by Joe Cosentino.